Vacation Rentals in Coney Island

Vacation Rentals in Coney Island

Start comparing over 7 rentals in Coney Island and book at the best price!

Find Vacation Rentals in Coney Island

Highlights Coney Island

  • Coastal rentals
  • Destination in New York
  • Family getaway
  • Outdoor adventures
  • Historical landmarks
  • Hiking trails

Prices and availability

Current Vacation rental prices Coney Island

$176for 29 Jun - 6 Jul
$226 annual average
Average price per week

Current vacation rental availability Coney Island

< 1%for 29 Jun - 6 Jul
0% annual average
Percentage of available rentals

Vacation rentals in Coney Island

Wonderful rental locations in Coney Island

Plan a trip to this quaint neighborhood for your next vacation destination in New York. The peninsular neighborhood of Coney Island is filled with entertainment and activities. You will find this neighborhood located in the southwestern part of New York City, right next to Brooklyn. The neighborhood is bordered by Brighton Beach, Lower New York Bay, Gravesend, as well as includes parts of Sea Gate and Brighton Beach. With a rich and extensive history, the name of this neighborhood has been disputed for years, however, the area was originally part of the Gravesend colonial town. Here you will be able to find historical landmarks, recreational activities and many other ways to enjoy your stay.

Vacation Rentals in Coney Island

You will be able to find plenty of ideal rental properties while staying in Coney Island. Whether you want to be located closer to the seaside or near to the center of the neighborhood, you will be able to choose from numerous options. Imagine spending your afternoon having brunch on your balcony as you overlook the beach. Have an afternoon out by your private pool sunbathing or enjoying a barbecue with your friends. Cozy up by the fireplace during a cold winter night playing board games with your loved ones. These are just some of the opportunities waiting for you with accommodation in Coney Island.

Vacations in Coney Island

The area and getting around

How to get to Coney Island

Making your way to Coney Island will be quite easy. The neighborhood is located in the southern part of Brooklyn and about one hour by subway from Times Square. With the subway, you can take the Q line, F line or D line to the "Coney Island- Stillwell Avenue" station. However, you will also be able to take a train to Penn Station from many cities around the United States of America. Another easy way to make your trip to Coney Island is by plane. The nearest airport to Coney Island is the New York JFK Airport, the Newark Airport and the New York La Guardia, all of which provide commercial flights from national and international destinations.

Where to eat in Coney Island

You will be delighted by the number of restaurants available for you to try out in Coney Island. From upscale dining experiences to casual lunch spots, there is plenty to satisfy your appetite. For a delicious slice of pizza, check out Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano. This restaurant has been open for 100 years, ever since 1921 this family-run restaurant will provide you with the best thin-crust, Neapolitan-style pizzas in the area. On the other hand, if you are looking for something fancier, check out Gargiulos Coney Island. This eatery opened up in 1907 as well and it will serve you a menu of classic Italian cuisine in a very extravagant atmosphere.

Travelers and activities

Coney Island for outdoor explorers

There are many ways to discover the stunning nature of Coney Island during your stay. One of the most gorgeous trails in the area is the Marine Park Salt Marsh Nature Trail. This short trail is perfect for people of all ages and it will take you through the local flora and fauna to end up in a stunning park where you can end the hike with a picnic. If you are more inclined to biking, you can ride to Coney Island starting at Machate Circle at the southern part of Prospect Park and down Ocean Parkway following a 5.5 miles bike path that will take you by the coast.

Coney Island for family activities

If you are taking the family to Coney Island with you for vacation, these activities will be delightful to try out altogether. One of the most iconic activities for families in the area is going to Deno’s Wonder Wheel Amusement Park. This stunning Ferris wheel was built back in 1920 near the boardwalk and it will give you one of the best views of all the neighborhood. Another great activity can be found at the MCU Park. Here you can catch an exciting baseball game and cheer on the local team, the Brooklyn Cyclones.

Did you know that the 80-foot wide boardwalk was nicknamed “Coney Island's Fifth Avenue"?

Top 5 travel tips for Coney Island

1. Try out Feltman's Hot Dogs

This iconic staple of Coney Island has been a legend since 1869. Do not miss out on the chance to try out the famous and original Coney Island hot dog while visiting the area.

2. Nathan's Famous Hot Dog Eating Contest

It is no surprise, but Coney Island is the capital of hot dogs. Nathan is another famous hot dog place in the neighborhood and it yearly provides an eating contest where participants come from all over the world to join.

3. Riegelmann Boardwalk

This 2.7-mile long plank that crosses the southern side of the neighborhood is where you will find the amusement park. Also, it was recognized as a New York City designated landmark.

4. Coney Island Beach

During a warm summer day, head over to Coney Island Beach. Here you will have the chance to relax, sunbathe, go for a swim or even play a round of beach volleyball.

5. Coney Island Museum

If you want to learn about the local history, head to this museum. The establishment has a permanent collection of over 5,000 items which include photographs, paintings, and vintage signs from over the years.

FAQs: Vacation Rentals in Coney Island

How much do the vacation rentals in Coney Island cost on average?

Last year, rentals in Coney Island had an annual average cost of around $171 per night.

Which months allow you to save the most on vacation rentals?

Those who want to be budget-friendly should visit Coney Island in May, June, or August, the cheapest months of the year, with average prices of $149, $157, and $158 per night, respectively, based on the previous year.

During which months are vacation rentals more expensive in Coney Island?

It can be concluded, by analyzing the data from the previous year, that costs per night for accommodation here are usually higher, on average, during the months of February ($204), January ($199), and December ($184).

Do I need to plan a trip to Coney Island well in advance?

If you decide to put Coney Island on your bucket list, we recommend organizing your vacation long before you go because it is usually very high in demand, with an annual average of 92% of rentals booked the previous year.

What time of the year can I find more available vacation rentals?

Last year, the months with the largest number of accommodations available of the year in Coney Island were October, September and February, with average availabilities of 29%, 25%, and 11%, respectively.

How many rentals are there in Coney Island?

We have 40 properties for you in Coney Island, provided by our 3 local and international partners.

Holidu compares hundreds of websites to find your perfect holiday rental for the best price.

500+ more