Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Start comparing over 317 rentals in Fire Island and book at the best price!

Search millions of vacation rentals
+
Compare over 1500 websites
=
Find your perfect vacation rental at the best price

Find offers

Free cancellation
Vacation house
Vacation apartment
Pool
Internet
Pets allowed
4.0
& higher
4.5
& higher

Popular Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
show all

from
$292
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with garden
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 0.8mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
2.3
(5 reviews)

from
$328
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people
10 pers., 4 bedrooms, 958ft², 2mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
(20 reviews)

from
$562
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people
10 pers., 4 bedrooms, 1,033ft², 2mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.0
(21 reviews)
show all

Vacation rentals with free cancellation
show all

from
$738
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people, with ocean view
10 pers., 4 bedrooms, 2,497ft², 1.8mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
(3 reviews)

from
$1,493
per night

Vacation rental for 8 people, with ocean view
8 pers., 4 bedrooms, 0.8mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
3.8
(2 reviews)

from
$916
per night

Vacation rental for 8 people, with ocean view, child-friendly
8 pers., 4 bedrooms, 1,195ft², 800yd to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
show all

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
show all

from
$917
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with balcony and jacuzzi, with pets
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 1,001ft², 1.9mi to the beach
5.0
(11 reviews)

from
$313
per night

Vacation rental for 2 people
2 pers., 355ft², 1.9mi to the beach
5.0
(11 reviews)

from
$417
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people, with jacuzzi and pool
10 pers., 3 bedrooms, 1,399ft², 1.9mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.1
(7 reviews)

from
$468
per night

Vacation rental for 9 people
9 pers., 4 bedrooms, 1mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.6
(11 reviews)

from
$496
per night

Vacation rental for 12 people, with jacuzzi
12 pers., 3 bedrooms, 2,250ft², 1.9mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.1
(14 reviews)

from
$993
per night

Vacation rental for 12 people, with pets
12 pers., 4 bedrooms, 0.8mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
3.8
show all

Pet-friendly Vacation Rentals
show all

from
$967
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with pool and balcony as well as jacuzzi, with pets
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 400yd to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
(3 reviews)

from
$1,690
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with jacuzzi and balcony as well as pool, child-friendly
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 2,497ft², 0.6mi to the beach
4.1
(4 reviews)

from
$586
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with pets
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 980ft², 1.8mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.4
(2 reviews)
show all

Vacation Rentals with Pool
show all

from
$993
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people, with pool, child-friendly
10 pers., 4 bedrooms, 3,617ft², 0.9mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
(4 reviews)

from
$1,058
per night

Vacation rental for 10 people, with ocean view and pool
10 pers., 5 bedrooms, 7,395ft², 1.9mi to the beach
FREE cancellation

from
$709
per night

Vacation rental for 8 people, with pool and garden, child-friendly
8 pers., 3 bedrooms, 1,496ft², 1.2mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
3.8
(4 reviews)
show all

Vacation Rentals with Internet
show all

from
$477
per night

Cottage for 6 people
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 797ft², 1.7mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
4.5
(5 reviews)

from
$794
per night

Vacation rental for 8 people, with jacuzzi and balcony, child-friendly
8 pers., 4 bedrooms, 3.2mi to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0

from
$974
per night

Vacation rental for 6 people, with pool and garden
6 pers., 3 bedrooms, 800yd to the beach
FREE cancellation
5.0
show all

Find Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Map

Most popular in Fire Island

Pool 27
Internet 113
Pets allowed 47
Balcony/Terrace 45
TV 105
Air conditioning 105

Other property types in Fire Island that might be interesting:

Prices and availability

Prices

October
November
December
January
February
March
$862
Sep 25 - Oct 02
$831 per night
Oct 02 - Oct 09
$784 per night
Oct 09 - Oct 16
$728 per night
Oct 16 - Oct 23
$721 per night
Oct 23 - Oct 30
$758 per night
Oct 30 - Nov 06
$808 per night
Nov 06 - Nov 13
$795 per night
Nov 13 - Nov 20
$734 per night
Nov 20 - Nov 27
$740 per night
Nov 27 - Dec 04
$805 per night
Dec 04 - Dec 11
$814 per night
Dec 11 - Dec 18
$804 per night
Dec 18 - Dec 25
$804 per night
Dec 25 - Jan 01
$841 per night
Jan 01 - Jan 08
$0 per night
Jan 08 - Jan 15
$862 per night
Jan 15 - Jan 22
$0 per night
Jan 22 - Jan 29
$829 per night
Jan 29 - Feb 05
$730 per night
Feb 05 - Feb 12
$0 per night
Feb 12 - Feb 19
$0 per night
Feb 19 - Feb 26
$735 per night
Feb 26 - Mar 05
$774 per night
Mar 05 - Mar 12
$0 per night
Average price per week

Availabilities

October
November
December
January
February
March
50 %
Sep 25 - Oct 02
36 %
Oct 02 - Oct 09
43 %
Oct 09 - Oct 16
46 %
Oct 16 - Oct 23
49 %
Oct 23 - Oct 30
50 %
Oct 30 - Nov 06
40 %
Nov 06 - Nov 13
41 %
Nov 13 - Nov 20
40 %
Nov 20 - Nov 27
39 %
Nov 27 - Dec 04
37 %
Dec 04 - Dec 11
36 %
Dec 11 - Dec 18
36 %
Dec 18 - Dec 25
36 %
Dec 25 - Jan 01
36 %
Jan 01 - Jan 08
37 %
Jan 08 - Jan 15
37 %
Jan 15 - Jan 22
37 %
Jan 22 - Jan 29
37 %
Jan 29 - Feb 05
36 %
Feb 05 - Feb 12
37 %
Feb 12 - Feb 19
37 %
Feb 19 - Feb 26
37 %
Feb 26 - Mar 05
1 %
Mar 05 - Mar 12
1 %
Percentage of available rentals

FAQs: Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

On average, what was the cost for vacation rentals in Fire Island in 2020, during the corona crisis?

Fire Island is the most exclusive city in the USA, with a cost of $765.41 on average per night.

Which months allow you to save the most on vacation rentals?

Travelers who want to save as much as possible travel to Fire Island in May, April, and October, which are the months that offer the most discount, with average prices of $661.38, $668.18, and $690.86 per night, respectively, based on data collected in 2020.

During which months are vacation rentals more expensive in Fire Island?

In 2020, the month that offered the highest average prices in Fire Island was July, with an average price of $919.28 per night. This was followed by August, with an average of $852.9, and June, with $845.1.

Should I plan a trip to Fire Island well in advance?

So you don't run out of accommodation options in Fire Island, we recommend you to plan ahead as 74% of rentals are usually booked, according to the data in 2020.

What time of the year can I find more free vacation rentals?

May, January and October are, in order of highest to lowest, the months that present the largest number of properties free, with respective average availability figures of 41.6%, 36.5%, and 36.2%.

When are fewer rentals available in Fire Island?

Vacation rentals in Fire Island reach their peak in demand in August, with an availability rate of 0.6%. The second most requested month is July, with 1.25%, and the third is September with 16%.

Are there many rentals in Fire Island?

In Fire Island we work with 3 different providers to give you a choice of 180 properties, so you will not be short of options!

Holidu compares hundreds of websites to find your perfect holiday rental for the best price.

Booking.com Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandBooking.com Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandHomeAway Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandHomeAway Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandFeWo-direkt Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandFeWo-direkt Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandVrbo Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandVrbo Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandHRS Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandHRS Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAbritel Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAbritel Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAirbnb Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAirbnb Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
  1. Vacation Rentals
  2. USA
  3. New York State
  4. Long Island
  5. Fire Island