Find Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Highlights Fire Island

  • Seaside rentals
  • Destination in New York
  • Family getaway
  • Historical destination
  • Natural landscapes
  • Water sports

Best Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.
Ocean Beach (ny), Suffolk County
Vacation Rental • 1593 ft² • 3 Bedrooms
(9 reviews)
Our home is available to rent monthly as well as weekly. Please note that we are on a very quiet block and we do not accommodate multiple families or beer pong aficionados!3 Bedroom, 1 & 1/2 bath home steps from the beach and a short stroll to the Village of Ocean Beach.Our traditional Fire Island home is in a great location and has everything to make your stay as enjoyable as possible. There is a really nice deck with a great outdoor shower. Inside is a large living room with smart t.v and a separate eat-in-kitchen. We have a.c. and wi-fi, beach chairs, towels and even a beach wagon to...
from $791 / night
Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation Rental • 1593 ft² • 3 Bedrooms
(10 reviews)
Two story house. Master bedroom with queen bed and two twin beds upstairs. Downstairs guest bedroom, with a full bed that sleeps two. House was remodeled years ago with new siding, roof, windows, ceiling fans and skylights. Wrap around deck surrounds the house with multiple sitting areas for individual privacy while viewing the birds and garden. House has wonderful, powerful outdoor shower next to the storage shed. Indoors, it has one full bathroom with tub and shower downstairs and a half bathroom with toilet and sink upstairs. Kitchen is fully equipped with a refrigerator, dishwasher and ...
from $645 / night
Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation Rental • 990 ft² • 2 Bedrooms
(10 reviews)
A 6 night minimum stay is required. Check in and check out is at noon at FireIslandEscape com Our property includes 2 bedrooms (sleeps 5 adults) plus an over sized day bed in the living room (sleeps 6). There is a large deck with plenty of outdoor seating, grill and private outdoor shower. Upon request the second bedroom will be converted into a king size bed (see photos) The great room is perfect for dining and entertaining. This beach home is meticulously clean and fully stocked. There are very few rentals in the area that will live up to your expectations. This one will! The kitchen is ...
from $607 / night

Other property types in Fire Island that might be interesting:

Prices and availability

Current Vacation rental prices Fire Island

$718for 1 Apr - 8 Apr
$838 annual average
Average price per week

Current vacation rental availability Fire Island

37%for 1 Apr - 8 Apr
39% annual average
Percentage of available rentals

Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Marvelous rental locations in Fire Island

Plan your next trip in the stunning area of Fire Island. You will find the destination in the center of the outer barrier islands in front of the south side of Long Island in the state of New York, United States of America. The name Fire Island is sometimes also used to refer to all of the islands in this area, including the Long Beach Barrier island, Jones Beach Island and Westhampton Island. Technically divided into two islands since 2012, Fire Islands are about 3.1 miles long and between 500 to 1000 feet wide and are both parts of Suffolk County. If you are looking for a tranquil place for vacation, you will be glad to know that the permanent population of this island is about 292 inhabitants year-round. However, being a popular beach spot, during the summers the population expands to thousands.

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Being an island, you will find that plenty of rental properties in the area will be able to provide you with a stunning and scenic view. Whether you want to be located closer to the boutiques and bars or near the beach, the options are endless in Fire Island. Imagine having your morning tea sitting on your porch feeling the fresh sea breeze. Invite friends over for a dip in your private pool or a barbecue in your backyard. Have a glass of wine in the evening as you watch the sunset over the sea. These are some of the many opportunities awaiting in Fire Island.

Vacations in Fire Island

The area and getting around

There are plenty of ways to make your journey to Fire Island with a handful of modes of transportation. The best way to arrive at Fire Island is by boat. You will be able to find passenger ferries that service routes from mainland Long Island to Fire Island. These ferry terminals are located on Long Island and can be accessed by train and by car from all over. The three major airports in the area are John F. Kennedy International Airport, Newark Liberty International Airport and LaGuardia Airport, which operate commercial flights to destinations all over the nation and internationally.

Where to eat in Fire Island

Being a popular spot in the summer, you will find that the people of Fire Island have plenty of eateries for their guests to enjoy. Head to the Albatross for one of the most loved restaurants on the island. Being open for decades, this place is filled with a full bar, outdoor patio and a menu full of fresh seafood. Another great breakfast place is The Baywalk Cafe. This local spot will serve you Acai bowls, smoothies, egg sandwiches, and iced coffee.

Travelers and activities

Fire Island for outdoor explorers

There are many ways to enjoy the outdoors in Fire Island. One of the best local activities is beachcombing. You can go search for hidden treasures on the beaches of Fire Island, you will be able to find shells, marine plants, and exotic finds. Another way to enjoy the outdoors is by biking around the island. This is the best way to get around town and explore the untouched paths around the beaches.

Fire Island for family activities

If you choose to make your trip to Fire Island with your whole family, check out one of these fun activities. If you want to enjoy nature with your kids, check out the Sayville Marina Park. Here you will be able to walk through nature trails and admire the local flora and fauna. On the other hand, Wood Kingdom is a great playground to bring your kids. Filled with jungle gyms, picnic tables and public bathrooms, you will be able to have a fun afternoon in this place.

Did you know that the original Algonquin name for Fire Island translates to Seal Island due to the seals that wintered there?

Top 5 travel tips for Fire Island

1.Robert Moses State Park

You will find this splendid park located at the western part of Fire Island. This 875-acre state park is the oldest state park on Long Island and has many outdoor activities and attractions to enjoy.

2. Fire Island Lighthouse

This well-known landmark can be found in the Great South Bay. Originally built in 1826 this place served as a navigating beacon until 1974 for the boats passing by the coast.

3.Sunken Forest

This Maritime Holly Forest is situated in Sailor’s Haven. The place is named for its unusual location, this forest is filled with dunes that give it the appearance of being below sea level.


Take a break from your activities to enjoy some local comfort food. This nautical-themed restaurant has a menu with seafood and burgers, wraps, and quesadillas.

5. Smith Point County Park

Spend a relaxing day at the beach. This is considered to be one of the best beaches in the area and will allow you to peacefully sunbathe, go surfing and even fishing

FAQs: Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

How much do you pay, on average, for vacation rentals in Fire Island?

Fire Island is one of the most expensive cities in the USA. For a vacation rental here, you can expect to pay around $831 per night.

When are vacation rentals cheaper in Fire Island?

If it is your aim to save the maximum during your visit to Fire Island, pack your bags and travel there in October ($758 per night on average), November ($809), or April ($813), to find the lowest prices for the whole year.

In which months is it more expensive to rent a vacation rental in Fire Island?

At the time of booking a vacation rental in Fire Island, the highest prices can usually be seen in the month of February (with an average of $886 per night), followed by January ($878), and then March ($863).

Is Fire Island a good location for a last-minute getaway?

We recommend you to book in advance in Fire Island as only 19% of the properties are available throughout the year, according to last year's data.

What are the best months for a spontaneous getaway?

February, October and November are, in order of highest to lowest, the months offering the largest number of properties available, with an average availability of 44%, 39%, and 28%. However, even during these months, when rental availability is the highest, the average is just 37%. So it is still important you always book your vacation early Fire Island.

How many rentals does Holidu have in Fire Island?

We have grouped together the offers from 2 different partners in Fire Island, so we can offer you around 170 properties. You're going to have a hard time deciding which one to go with!

Holidu compares hundreds of websites to find your perfect holiday rental for the best price. Vacation Rentals in Fire Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Airbnb Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAirbnb Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Vrbo Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandVrbo Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Bookiply Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandBookiply Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
FeWo-direkt Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandFeWo-direkt Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Abritel Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandAbritel Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
HRS Vacation Rentals in Fire IslandHRS Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
500+ more
  1. Vacation Rentals
  2. USA
  3. New York State
  4. Long Island
  5. Fire Island