Beach houses on Fire Island

Beach houses on Fire Island

64 properties for Beach Rentals. Compare and book at the best price!

Popular Beach Rentals in Fire Island

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

9.8

Vacation house for 10 people, with balcony, with pets

Free cancellation

from $1,075 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 19 people, with balcony

from $1,466 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.7

Vacation house for 6 people, with yard

Free cancellation

from $803 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 12 people, with terrace

from $2,030 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

6.6

Vacation house for 10 people, with sauna and balcony, with pets

Free cancellation

from $866 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.1

Vacation house for 8 people, with terrace

from $1,245 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.3

Vacation house for 12 people, with terrace, with pets

Free cancellation

from $872 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.4

Vacation house for 8 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $1,115 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.7

Vacation house for 6 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $835 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

9.9

Vacation house for 5 people

Free cancellation

from $530 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.9

Vacation house for 10 people, with balcony

Free cancellation

from $1,363 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.8

Vacation house for 12 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $802 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 10 people, with terrace and yard

Free cancellation

from $1,611 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 10 people, with terrace

from $1,503 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 10 people

Free cancellation

from $1,168 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 6 people, with yard and hot tub

Free cancellation

from $1,501 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.5

Vacation house for 6 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $595 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 8 people, with balcony and yard, with pets

from $1,777 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

9.8

Vacation house for 10 people, with balcony

Free cancellation

from $1,517 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 8 people, with terrace and hot tub

Free cancellation

from $1,252 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 8 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $851 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

9.6

Vacation house for 10 people, with terrace

Free cancellation

from $1,458 per night

Fire Island, Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 8 people, with balcony and yard

Free cancellation

from $1,213 per night

Ocean Beach (NY), Suffolk County

10.0

Vacation house for 15 people, with terrace, with pets

Free cancellation

from $1,509 per night

Find Beach Rentals in Fire Island

Highlights in Fire Island

  • Fire Island Beach Getaway
  • Charming beach houses
  • Perfect summer retreat
  • Beach attractions
  • Atlantic Coast barrier island retreat

Best Beach Rentals in Fire Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.
Vacation House for 10 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House for 10 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 1
Vacation House for 10 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 2
Vacation House for 10 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 3
Vacation House for 10 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 4
more...
Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House • 10 Guests • 4 Bedrooms
10.0
(14 reviews)
2026 Summer Season Welcome to our listing and thank you for your interest in our summer home. The summers we have spent in Seaview have led to many fun days, relaxing nights, and priceless memories with family and friends. We hope you will choose to stay with us so you too can build lasting memories of summering in Fire Island. The house offers the ideal setting for an affordable fun family vacation or for a couple looking for a relaxing and romantic getaway. You will be located just 2 houses from the bay and 2 blocks from the Ocean in the beautiful Town of Seaview. Seaview is considered by...
from $1,302 / night
Vacation House for 8 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House for 8 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 1
Vacation House for 8 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 2
Vacation House for 8 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 3
Vacation House for 8 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 4
more...
Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House • 1399 ft² • 4 Bedrooms
10.0
(21 reviews)
Welcome to our home in Seaview, Fire Island. Seaview is one of the most sought-after communities on the island. You can walk or bicycle to the beach, bay, or nearby communities with a variety of restaurants and shopping. Our home is on C Street, one block from the ferry terminal, and one and one half blocks, a 2-minute walk, from the ocean and bay. The Town of Ocean Beach is just a five minute walk away. Why settle for less when you can enjoy this beautiful, clean, light and airy, fully renovated home to experience the unique pleasures of Fire Island? There is no need to compromise your tas...
from $860 / night
Vacation House for 12 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House for 12 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 1
Vacation House for 12 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 2
Vacation House for 12 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 3
Vacation House for 12 Guests in Fire Island, Suffolk County, Picture 4
more...
Fire Island, Suffolk County
Vacation House • 1292 ft² • 4 Bedrooms
9.0
(24 reviews)
Handkerchief House VIDEO WALK THRU Charming beach house in Ocean Ridge Section of Davis Park, Fire Island Community. Only a 20 minute ferry ride from Patchogue Terminal. House is a one of a kind structure with water views on all balconies A relaxing retreat. 4 bedrooms/ 2 bathroom with 2 queen Futons for additional sleeping upstairs. All kitchen,bath and beach amenities included . Open layout with entertaining kitchen and countertop with dining up to 8 people. Large Outdoor Deck and additional dining table, large gas grill, sunbathing , outside shower. A/C in all rooms, One California KING,...
from $945 / night

Other holiday ideas and property types in Fire Island that might be interesting

Beach Houses on Fire Island

Stunning beach house locations on Fire Island

Fire Island is a beloved summer escape from the mayhem and hustle of New York City. Just 65 miles east of Manhattan via the Southern State Parkway lies a secluded, barrier island, Atlantic Coast haven, waiting to be discovered! Your senses will be dazzled by gorgeous white sand beaches, enticing ocean waves and pretty, safe, immaculate seaside towns with absolutely no cars! Park your car at the lighthouse upon arrival and get ready to get around the old fashioned way on foot or by rental bike!

Long Island Wilderness Destination

Fire Island is a 32 mile long, 0.5 mile, pine needle thin, Atlantic ocean barrier island that lies parallel to Long Island. Only a couple of hours by ferry from Manhattan this chilled out, remote destination where your idyllic beach house accommodation is situated has everything you need for a superb stay. Unspoiled, pristine, wilderness, white sand beaches within walking distance provide a haven of peace that is as close to nature as you can get. There are bustling villages with charming restaurants and shops aplenty on this small, whimsical island where there is no traffic or traffic pollution! Many of the stunning wood build beach house rentals in this area have a private pool, a yard and a gorgeous outdoor deck with a view of the ocean

Travelers and activities

Fire Island for water sport enthusiasts

With so many miles of pristine, soft sand beaches to choose from with lovely conditions for swimming, surfing, windsurfing and stand up paddleboarding, you will be spoiled for choice for gloriously relaxing days out at the beach. There are long stretches of unforgettably beautiful shoreline for long walks by the sea in this surfing paradise with the Atlantic ocean on one side and the calmer waters of Great South Bay on the other.

Fire Island for lovers of charming beach towns

Visitors love the laid back beach vibe of the peaceful, residential communities on Fire Island that are also home to shops, marinas and lovely restaurants and ice cream parlors. Kismet, located west and closest to Fire Island’s iconic lighthouse, has two restaurants and a wonderful pizza shack. Saltaire is a beautiful residential community with great views and Fair Harbor boasts quaint walkways and fine dining. Atlantique is a quiet haven with limited access while gorgeous Ocean Beach has gift shops, clothing stores and several vibrant restaurants and bars. Cherry Grove is lively and bohemian. Convenient, fun water taxi services link the different Fire Island communities in season.

Did you know, as there are no roads or cars on Fire Island- you will find visitors and residents alike transporting heavy goods in little red wagons available at the ferry terminals!

FAQs: Beach Rentals in Fire Island

Which types of facilities are available at the beach houses in Fire Island?

In regards to the services you can find on Holidu, it seems that the beach houses in Fire Island have everything that travelers search for! Here, the beach houses generally include a variety of amenities, the most popular being: internet (97%), barbecue (92%), and air-conditioning (92%)...Are you convinced yet?

How are the reviews for the beach houses in Fire Island?

The beach houses here often get a lot of positive comments. 65% of the beach houses in Fire Island have excellent reviews and an average score of 4.5 stars!

Are the beach houses in Fire Island child-friendly?

According to the Holidu database, 82% of beach houses in Fire Island are suitable for families with children, so you won't struggle finding the ideal beach house for you and your children.

Are the beach houses in Fire Island suitable for travelers and their pets?

Of course! In Fire Island, 26% of the beach houses give you the opportunity to bring along your furry best friend, 21% even have a garden!

Do the beach houses in Fire Island often have an internet connection?

Of course! According to Holidu's data, 97% of beach houses in Fire Island include Wi-Fi. This means that you will be able to stay connected at any time!

What are the prices like for beach houses in Fire Island?

Many beach houses in Fire Island are, in general, very expensive. According to the last year, 87% are at more than $500 a night.

Do the beach houses in Fire Island usually have a fireplace or a pool?

Definitely! Based on last year, a lot of beach houses in Fire Island are equipped with a fireplace. Perfect for a cozy winter vacation!

Are the beach houses in Fire Island suitable for trips with friends or rather for a vacation as a small group?

Here, according to the last year, 81% of beach houses are suitable for groups of up to eight guests, 73% of these beach houses are made up of at least four bedrooms. But 100% of beach houses also accept up to four people, 100% of the beach houses are made up of at least two separate bedrooms. This is therefore the perfect destination for groups of friends of all sizes!

Do the beach houses in Fire Island offer outdoor space to enjoy?

27% of beach houses have a balcony or terrace, and 31% have a view, but since this does not represent the majority so availability can be limited. If this is important to you, you should anticipate a bit more time for research, and use the filters to be sure to find the beach house perfect for you. However, 21% of beach houses in Fire Island have gardens, where you can bask in the sun. If you like to have lunch or dinner outside, and especially if you like barbecues, 92% of the beach houses have them.

Holiday destinations nearby for Beach Rentals